The winners for the 2009 ENnies, the yearly RPG awards, have been announced at Gen Con. Let’s review and see how that stacks up to my picks.
Best Cover Art:
- Gold: CthulhuTech, Catalyst Game Labs
- Silver: Pathfinder #19: Howl of the Carrion King, Paizo Publishing
I had picked 3:16 for the win, though the CT art is nice enough. There were a lot of good covers this year.
Best Interior Art
- Gold: Dark Heresy, Fantasy Flight Games
- Silver: Mouse Guard, Kinoichi / Archaia Studio Press
I had actually picked CthulhuTech for this category instead. I feel like the winners for interior art, cover art, and production values are just assigned at random from the “pretty games,” not sure people really distinguish correctly. In this case I like Dark Heresy’s production values, but the interior art is sparse enough I don’t think it deserves a win for this subcategory specifically. What art there is splits between good and “black blob style.” The good ones are really really good but… Gold is a stretch.
Best Cartography
- Gold: Pathfinder Chronicles Second Darkness Map Folio, Paizo Publishing
- Silver: Star Wars: Scum and Villainy, Wizards of the Coast
Exactly my picks in that order.
Best Writing
- Gold: Kobold Quarterly, Open Design
- Silver: Don’t Lose Your Mind, Evil Hat Productions
I had picked Don’t Lose Your Mind for the gold. Nothing against KQ, it’s serviceable writing equivalent to Dragon Magazine of times of yore, but this is an instance where the “D&D popularity” factor overwhelms actually artistically superior work.
Best Production Values
- Gold: Dark Heresy, Fantasy Flight Games
- Silver: Mouse Guard, Kinoichi / Archaia Studios Press
Though all pretty, I thought the game Anima was actually higher in this all around area. But it was a very tight field this year with many very deserving contestants. Yay to everyone.
Best Rules
- Gold: Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition Players Handbook, Wizards of the Coast
- Silver: A Song of Ice and Fire Roleplaying, Green Ronin Publishing
I had picked Dark Heresy for best rules. Though it’s pretty, I don’t think its art should have won over other contenders, but its rules really are better than 4e’s. “Of course I hate 4e so I’d say that.” I like Green Ronin but don’t find the SIFRPG rules really that awe-inspiring; they seem more servicable as the line is more about the setting.
Best Adventure
- Gold: Pathfinder #19: Howl of the Carrion King, Paizo Publishing
- Silver: P1 King of the Trollhaunts Warrens, Wizards of the Coast
Of course Pathfinder for the gold, they make the best adventures hands down. Not familiar with “Trollhaunts Warrens” but I never hear anyone talking about it online (while they do talk about Shadowfell Keep, etc.) so I’m suspicious on that count.
Best Monster Supplement
- Gold: Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition Monster Manual, Wizards of the Coast
- Silver: Dark Heresy Creatures Anathema, Fantasy Flight Games
Oh, major boner here in leaving out Freedom’s Most Wanted for Mutants & Masterminds. And the MM has been one of the least well received 4e books, definitely no brilliant new monsters that will be part of everyday RPG conversation. Well, the ENnies got their start coattailing on the 3e release so I reckon you can’t criticize them for sticking close to their roots.
Best Setting
- Gold: Pathfinder Chronicles Campaign Setting, Paizo Publishing
- Silver: Swashbucklers of the 7 Skies, Atomic Sock Monkey / Evil Hat Productions
Golarion, the setting of the Pathfinder Chronicles, is the new Greyhawk. It’s the clear winner, which is a little bit of a shame since the rest of the field is very innovative too – Hot War and Candlewick Manor I wouldn’t have minded seeing in a three way tie for second… Setting and production values had a lot of very qualified nominees this year.
Best Supplement
- Gold: CthulhuTech Vade Mecum, Catalyst Game Labs
- Silver: Star Wars: The Clone Wars, Wizards of the Coast
I had picked Clone Wars, definitely. Good for Cthulhutech for grabbing the gold. I just can’t get into the game, and this is from someone who has a huge shelf of Call of Cthulhu stuff. And I’m an Evangelion fan to boot. You think those two would combine to make me love it but it just doesn’t grab me. But I don’t begrudge it a win.
Best Aid or Accessory
- Gold: D&D Insider, Wizards of the Coast
- Silver: Kobold Quarterly, Open Design
Spare me. The most delayed, incomplete, incompetent item on the list gets the gold? Let’s give Boston’s Big Dig awards for engineering too! (Well, people have in that case as well…) I am willing to say maybe the 4e rules could win best rules but Insider is one of the worst things WotC has failed to deliver on. They still haven’t delivered the stuff they said would be part of it at 4e launch! You only have to visit any online forum to see people unhappy with their current functionality as well.
I had picked KQ for the win, as a post-rant aside.
Best Miniatures Product
- Gold: Game Mastery Flip-mat: Waterfront Tavern, Paizo Publishing
- Silver: DU1 Halls of the Giant Kings Dungeon Tiles, Wizards of the Coast
I gave silver to the Tavern but the E-Z Terrain cliffs are so much neater than both these 2d tiles!
Best Regalia
- Gold: Battletech: The Corps, Catalyst Game Labs
- Silver: Art of Exalted, White Wolf Publishing
I refused to pick a winner here because “Regalia” is a totally stupid category that’s a mishmash of totally unrelated products. (I’m surprised the Gygax posthumous novel didn’t win out of sheer Gygaxity though.)
Best Electronic Book
- Gold: Collection of Horrors: Razor Kids, White Wolf Publishing
- Silver: Tales of Zobek: An Anthology of Urban Adventures, Open Design
I liked the other Open Design entry better since it’s by Nick Logue, but different strokes.
Best Free Product
- Gold: Song of Ice and Fire Quickstart, Green Ronin Publishing
- Silver: Swords and Wizardry, Mythmere Games
Sad. There was actually a movement generated by this category; many of the entries were quickstart rules, which should not be in this category. A company can spend their loads of money developing a game and them at no cost to them clip part of it out and release a “quickstart”. This category should be only for “real” free games that are full games released for free, not advertising teasers. The ENnie judges apparently don’t see the wisdom in that even though a lot of the community does.
I like Green Ronin but they don’t deserve a win in this category for this reason. I had picked S&W for the win.
Best Website
- Gold: Obsidian Portal
- Silver: Kobold Quarterly
I like Mad Brew Labs more but these are great sites too.
Best Podcast
- Gold: All Games Considered
- Silver: Order 66
I don’t listen to podcasts, so have no opinion.
Best Game
- Gold: Dungeons and Dragons 4th Edition, Wizards of the Coast
- Silver: Dark Heresy, Fantasy Flight Games
Dark Heresy was my pick here! (I am disregarding 4e because it’s a plant, see below.)
Product of the Year
- Gold: Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition Players Handbook, Wizards of the Coast
- Silver: Mouse Guard, Kinoichi / Archaia Studios Press
Mouse Guard was my pick here! (I am disregarding 4e because it’s a plant, see below.) But this one is even more egregious. Mouse Guard is a) a complete game, b) uses innovative rules, c) merges with a rich licensed setting… The D&D PHB, even if you like 4e, is just player rules and is nowhere near a complete game.
Best Publisher
- Gold: Wizards of The Coast
- Silver: Paizo Publishing
And this boils down the suck-up nature of the ENnies to a clear point. The company that bungled the 4e launch, failed to deliver on D&D Insider, pulled all their PDF products off the market permanently, alienated the industry with the GSL and the fans with website shutdowns and failure (till after voting) to deliver a fansite policy – they’re “best publisher?” It’s OK to like 4e, but to pretend that WotC has done anything but fuck one thing after another up this year – this ENnie is like Pres. Bush giving the Medal of Freedom to George Tenet, or passing up Metallica for Foghat [edit: Jethro Tull] for a Grammy, it simply degrades the award’s worth in the future.
Conclusion – 2 Strikes For The ENnies
ENnies – you are on warning. Two strikes this year – allowing quickstarts to win in the Free Games category and in blindly allowing WotC/4e to win categories that they are clearly not contenders in (electronic product, best publisher especially). How is someone else supposed to feel good about their award when it’s clear so many of the decisions reward the *antithesis* of the award category?
Again, sure, maybe the 4e PHB wins best rules. But the across the board 4e/WotC wins in clearly laughable categories? What’s up with that?